Peter Denies the Pickoff

Three pickoff attempts. Three denials. The Peter Denies the Pickoff Collection from The Church of Baseball by The Craftsman’s Works brings biblical humor and baseball heritage together in one clever, vintage-inspired design.

Each piece, available as T-shirts, ¾ sleeve raglans, and heavyweight sweatshirts, features The Craftsman’s Works’ original Peter Denies the Pickoff Three Times artwork. It’s a tongue-in-cheek tribute to the tension between pitcher and runner, reimagined through the lens of faith and folklore.

Crafted from premium materials and printed with care, every shirt in this collection embodies the signature balance of quality, creativity, and nostalgia that defines The Craftsman’s Works.

Collection Highlights:

• Exclusive “Peter Denies the Pickoff” artwork – available only from The Craftsman’s Works

• Offered in T-shirts, ¾ sleeve raglans, and heavyweight sweatshirts

• Premium fabrics – soft, durable, and built for everyday wear

• Vintage baseball aesthetic – distressed print and classic typography

• Unisex, true-to-size fit for comfort on and off the field

Why You’ll Love It:

The Peter Denies the Pickoff Collection captures everything that makes baseball storytelling great — a mix of tension, humor, and divine irony. It’s designed for players, fans, and collectors who love the game’s wit as much as its tradition.

Perfect for wearing to the ballpark, gifting to a fellow believer in the Church of Baseball, or adding to your collection of vintage baseball apparel.

Faith, folklore, and flawless glove work — welcome to The Church of Baseball.

Own the story. Wear the legend. Shop the Peter Denies the Pickoff Collection.