How to Break in a Baseball Glove the Right Way

How to Break in a Baseball Glove the Right Way

A new baseball glove is exciting — the leather is crisp, the laces are tight, and the promise of seasons ahead is in your hands. But anyone who’s slipped on a brand-new mitt knows the truth: fresh gloves are stiff. To get your glove game-ready, you’ll need to break it in properly.

At The Craftsman’s Works, we specialize in glove care and glove conditioning. Here’s our step-by-step guide (inspired by this video) on how to break in your glove the right way, without damaging the leather.

Step 1: Soften the Leather with Glove Conditioner

The first step to breaking in a glove is getting the leather flexible. Apply a thin layer of Glove Lotion — never overdo it. This conditioner keeps the leather hydrated, prevents cracking, and makes the break-in smoother.

👉 Shop our Glove Lotion

Step 2: Shape the Pocket

The pocket is the heart of your glove. To shape it:

  • Place a ball in the pocket.

  • Close the glove around the ball.

  • Use a glove mallet (or your hands) to repeatedly pound the pocket.

This mimics real game action and helps form the glove to your natural catching motion.

Step 3: Work the Hinges

A stiff glove won’t close properly. Focus on the hinges of the glove — the areas near the thumb and pinky. Bend them back and forth, and use the mallet to pound the hinge areas. This allows for smooth, one-handed closure when you’re on the field.

Step 4: Play Catch (most important step)

There’s no substitute for real reps. Grab a partner and start playing catch. Each throw helps the glove naturally mold to your hand and your style of play.  If you don't have a partner, use a machine!  There is no substitute for catching a ball!

Step 5: Store It Properly

When you’re not using your glove, keep a ball in the pocket (especially for youth and outfield gloves), or leave it open with the palm facing down (especially for infield gloves). This locks in the shape and ensures your pocket stays defined.

What NOT to Do

We know there are plenty of “shortcuts” out there — baking gloves in the oven, soaking them in water, or microwaving them. Don’t do it. These methods damage the leather fibers and shorten the life of your glove. A proper break-in takes patience, but your glove will thank you with years of performance.

Final Thoughts

Breaking in a glove isn’t just about softening the leather — it’s about shaping it to your game. With the right glove care products and a little time, your mitt will feel like an extension of your hand.

Ready to start? Check out our glove care collection to keep your glove performing at its best.

Back to blog